|
Porcelain
has been in use for over 4000 years in China. It is made
from special white clay and fired at a temperature of 1280
degrees centigrade. There are a couple different ways in
which these items are decorated. The most common today is
molded, decorated, and glazed. Others are molded and
enameled then fired again. The third type is under glaze in
blue and red. The Chinese have always been extremely
proficient at porcelain work, and have produced numerous
pieces that look like coral, glass, stone, and many other
materials.
Chinese Porcelain by David Pullens
Since the Chinese did not produce large
numbers of snuff bottles of porcelain until about 1800
(during the Jiajing period) any porcelain snuff bottle
claiming to be before this date should be looked upon with
suspect. And as a general rule, the porcelain quality
(porcelain and not necessarily decoration) of Chinese pieces
has become progressively worse since the middle of the Qing
Dynasty (1644-1911) - since about 1780 - and so looking at
porcelain quality is very important in determining
age.
Concerning age, the most tell tale sign on
Chinese porcelain is the bottom and foot of a piece. This is
often frustrating when visiting a museum or exhibition
because more often than not the bases of pieces are not
visible and only such shows as say those put on by the Asia
Society or those run by ceramic societies have the sense to
display pieces so the bases are visible (they also tend to
have the specialized crowd to demand this). Having seen but
more importantly felt many bases of authenticated pieces of
different periods is (as with all antiques) always best in
understanding the differences observable over time and in
this way comparisons are possible. In general however, if
the thumb is taken and rubbed over the foot of the snuff
bottle, the porcelain body should be very smooth and without
much granulation.
New bottles may appear to be of fine
porcelain due to a heavy white and translucent glaze which
masks the often stoneware and not porcelain body. When the
foot is felt on most new pieces the texture could be
described as even abrasive in comparison to earlier pieces.
Very early pieces of porcelain produced during the Kangxi
reign (1662-1722) have a foot which could even be described
as silky to the touch, such was the quality and make up of
the porcelain body during this time. However, as was stated
the likelihood of finding such an early piece is next to
impossible and due to the often tiny foot of a porcelain
bottle, it may feel smoother than it would if the same
porcelain were used on a larger piece and with a larger foot
with more surface area.
A second check to make is that of the
enamels or under glaze decoration on the bottle. It is true
that there are monochrome bottles however the majority are
one of the above mentioned types. Comparing the enamels on
larger documented pieces which are not snuff bottles can
often lead to an attribution of a date to similarly
decorated snuff bottles. Those enamels in famille rose
should be pleasantly harmonious in a pastel palette and
never harsh in tint. On famille rose pieces, the newer the
pieces typically the greater the use of orange in the
palette as well and a lack of gold in the details.
Under glaze blue pieces were executed using
cobalt and therefore the color is not always consistent
(cobalt is still used, though some pieces use blue transfers
particularly on the cylindrical bottles and these lack the
following qualities in addition to having what can be
observed as innumerable dots under a magnification). In an
older piece the decoration should have variation! in color
and in particular, there should be "build up" of
cobalt, making it darker, at say the base of a line or
around the foot of the bottle where the liquid would
naturally accumulate.
The blue of newer pieces lacks the vibrancy
of color and often appears flat, having little variation and
usually the color borders on a dark navy or in the extreme
to a black which is not at all characteristic of 19th
century bottles. Regarding the decoration of both under
glaze blue and enameled bottles, with landscapes or figures
depicted, you should be impressed by the detail and
composition of the scene. You should look at the piece and
be amazed at how such precision was possible on such a small
object - as newer pieces often have coarsely painted and
clumsy subjects with little detail.
Finally you can look at the mark if one is
present. Marks so rarely are of the period of the snuff
bottle's production that they should only serve as a
confirmation of what has been determined by all other signs
of age. So often new collectors and dealers find a mark on a
piece of porcelain in one of the many books depicting them
and then assume that the piece is naturally of the reign
indicated by this mark. It is common to find them with the
marks of Yongzheng (1723-1735) or Qianlong (1736-1795) but
these are almost never of the period and those that are have
long ago found their way into museums. Just because of the
erroneous marks however, these pieces should not be
discounted because they are often of the Jiaing (1796-1820)
or Daoguang (1721-1850) periods. Marks should be executed in
an enamel in the palette of the piece or are often found in
red or under glaze blue. The mark should never appear to
have been stamped on the piece as so many new bottles do.
Also, just as attention to detail and quality in decoration
is important, the precision of the mark's depiction is
important and a sloppy mark is indication of either a late
date or a piece that may be early but is not necessarily of
any quality.
|